Shelf 5 · Economics · 35 / 45
Incidents & Turning Points
Mt.Gox, Silk Road, The DAO, FTX: a record of the events that shaped Bitcoin.
Check this article’s sources (29)Contents
Article brief
Exchanges disappeared while the network kept running. Even when the protocol held, people, companies, and law were shaken. Incident history teaches that difference.
Investigate each event by separating the bridge, the vehicle, the driver, and the traffic rules: protocol, wallet, exchange, organization, and regulation are distinct layers.
Where the analogy stops
Events have several causes at once, and chronology alone does not establish causation. An exchange failing is not the same thing as the Bitcoin protocol stopping.
Structure
When the news calls something a “Bitcoin failure,” you will ask what actually broke and what kept working.
Open the glossary1Silk Road (2011–2013)
Silk Road was an anonymous dark web marketplace founded in 2011 by "Dread Pirate Roberts" (Ross Ulbricht). Bitcoin was its only payment method.
In October 2013 the FBI shut down the site and arrested Ulbricht. About 144,000 BTC, worth $28.5 million at the time, were seized.
Ulbricht was convicted in 2015 on counts including narcotics distribution conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy, and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. On January 21, 2025 President Trump granted him a full and unconditional pardon, and he was released after roughly eleven years. Views on the pardon diverge sharply: supporters say the sentence was disproportionate for nonviolent offenses, while critics say the clemency discounts the harm done by the drugs sold through the site.
Silk Road cemented Bitcoin's image as "criminal money," but it also proved that Bitcoin works as a censorship-resistant way to move value.
The U.S. Marshals Service later auctioned the seized bitcoins, and venture capitalist Tim Draper bought them in bulk.
The case also changed how people thought about Bitcoin privacy: it showed that blockchain analysis can trace Bitcoin transactions, a point that became widely understood through this investigation.
2The full Mt.Gox story (2014)
Mt.Gox was founded in 2010 and at its peak handled roughly 70% of all Bitcoin transactions worldwide. It started life as a Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange, which is where the name comes from.
In February 2014 it announced the loss of about 850,000 BTC, worth $450 million at the time and tens of billions at current prices. Internal mismanagement and hacking were both blamed. What it filed with the Tokyo District Court on February 28 was not bankruptcy but civil rehabilitation; the case converted to bankruptcy proceedings that April and was moved back into civil rehabilitation by a commencement order on June 22, 2018. Creditor repayments today run under that civil rehabilitation framework.
The gap between the 850,000 BTC reported lost and the roughly 140,000 BTC later covered by repayments is explained by the discovery of about 200,000 BTC in an old-format wallet in March 2014. The effective loss was on the order of 650,000 BTC, and the recovered coins passed into the trustee's custody, becoming the source of the repayments a decade later.
The lesson that outlived the exchange: "Not your keys, not your coins" — if you do not control the private keys, you do not really own the coins. The phrase has been repeated ever since.
Former CEO Mark Karpelès stood trial in Japan and was found not guilty of embezzlement but guilty of data manipulation (unauthorized creation and use of electromagnetic records). On March 15, 2019 the Tokyo District Court sentenced him to two years and six months in prison, suspended for four years, far short of the ten years prosecutors had sought.
Creditor repayments began in 2024, nearly a decade later. They cover roughly 140,000 BTC and are proceeding in stages, including returns in kind; the repayment deadline has been extended several times and distributions are ongoing. The collapse became a turning point that fundamentally changed security standards across the entire crypto industry.
3The DAO hack and Ethereum's split (2016)
The DAO was a decentralized investment fund on Ethereum. In May 2016 it raised about $150 million, roughly 14% of all the ETH in existence at the time.
In June 2016 an attacker exploited a flaw in its smart contract and drained about 3.6 million ETH, worth roughly $50 million.
What makes this relevant to Bitcoin is the philosophical argument it started over "immutability." Ethereum hard-forked the following month, in July 2016, to reverse the attack, splitting into Ethereum (reversed) and Ethereum Classic (unchanged); the hack and the split did not happen in the same month.
The Bitcoin community read the episode as a lesson in why immutability matters. The shared understanding that a comparable rollback is unthinkable on Bitcoin is part of what the network is valued for.
4The block size war (2015–2017)
The most intense internal dispute in Bitcoin's history split the community over how to grow past the 1MB block size limit.
"Big blockers" (Roger Ver, Jihan Wu, and others) wanted to raise the block size directly through a hard fork and scale on-chain.
"Small blockers" (Gregory Maxwell, Pieter Wuille, and others) wanted SegWit, a soft fork, plus Layer 2 systems such as the Lightning Network.
On August 1, 2017 Bitcoin Cash (BCH) split off in a hard fork. SegWit activated on Bitcoin itself later that month, at block 481,824 on 24 August; the fork and the activation were not the same day.
The dispute forced the question of "who governs Bitcoin?" into the open. The outcome showed that node operators, meaning users, hold the final say (UASF: User Activated Soft Fork).
5A history of exchange hacks
Bitfinex (2016): about 120,000 BTC, worth roughly $72 million, was stolen. In 2022 the U.S. DOJ recovered $3.6 billion, at the time the largest crypto-related seizure on record.
Coincheck (2018): about $530 million worth of NEM (XEM) was drained from this Japanese exchange. Weak hot wallet management was the cause, and the theft brought stricter FSA rules. In March 2018 the company compensated roughly 260,000 affected users out of its own funds at ¥88.549 per XEM, about ¥46.3 billion in total. It received two business improvement orders from the FSA and became a wholly owned subsidiary of Monex Group that April.
Binance (7 May 2019): using phishing, viruses, and other attacks, the attackers obtained a large number of users' API keys and two-factor authentication codes, then used the hijacked accounts to request withdrawals and took 7,000 BTC (about $40 million, by Binance's account) in a single transaction. Only the exchange's BTC hot wallet, which held about 2% of its total BTC holdings, was affected. Binance suspended deposits and withdrawals for about a week and announced that its SAFU fund would cover the loss in full, with no user funds affected.
The incident even prompted public talk of a chain reorganization (reorg): miners coordinating to rewrite the chain so that the theft would no longer be valid. Undoing it would have required rebuilding the block containing the theft, and every block after it, with more work. On 8 May, after speaking with people including Jeremy Rubin and Jihan Wu, Binance's then-CEO Changpeng Zhao (CZ) said the exchange would not pursue a reorg. He cited the risk of damaging Bitcoin's credibility and of splitting the network and its community, and judged that both outweighed a $40 million act of revenge. The theft transaction is still recorded in block 575,013.
Binance (30 October 2026): Binance said its preliminary findings point to a compromised DevOps engineer's laptop, through which an attacker may have reached a service container and executed unauthorized withdrawals. It estimated the total impact at around $6.3 billion, with about $3 billion frozen on-chain, and said it had found no evidence of a wallet private key leak. Binance said the SAFU fund and company funds would cover the losses and that user funds were safe. Withdrawals were suspended and have been reopening asset by asset since 1 November; an update that day said about 95% of the impacted amount had been covered. The figures and the cause come from Binance's preliminary announcements; as of 3 November 2026 its post-incident report had not been published.
DMM Bitcoin (31 May 2024): 4,502.9 BTC, about ¥48.2 billion at the time, was drained from a wallet managed by this Japanese exchange. In December 2024 the National Police Agency of Japan, jointly with the FBI and the U.S. Department of Defense Cyber Crime Center (DC3), attributed the theft to TraderTraitor, a group with a North Korean background. The company compensated customers in full but gave up on continuing the business, transferring accounts and custodied assets to SBI VC Trade and shutting down its services in March 2025. It is a case of a registered Japanese exchange being wound up as a direct consequence of a theft.
Bybit (21 February 2025): 401,347 ETH plus stETH and other ETH derivatives, roughly $1.4-1.5 billion at the time in total, was drained from an Ethereum cold wallet. It was one of the largest crypto thefts at the time, more than three times the ~$450 million lost at Mt.Gox. The attackers compromised the development environment of the Safe{Wallet} multisig tooling and altered what the signers saw on their approval screens, so that they authorized a fraudulent transfer out of cold storage. The target was not the keys themselves but the screen the people approving the transaction were looking at. The FBI attributed the theft to North Korea, naming the activity "TraderTraitor". Bybit closed the resulting gap in customer assets within about 72 hours by raising funds externally.
The thefts listed here involved exchanges or surrounding tools. Bitcoin software has also had serious defects, including the unauthorized inflation incident in 2010 and a vulnerability fixed in 2018. Exchange compromises should be distinguished from defects in the protocol or its implementations (see "Bitcoin Vulnerabilities").
The lesson: do not keep large amounts of bitcoin on an exchange. Hold your own keys, with a hardware wallet or multisig.
6The FTX collapse (2022)
In November 2022 FTX, a major crypto exchange, collapsed. Former CEO Sam Bankman-Fried was arrested in the Bahamas on December 12 on charges related to misappropriating customer funds and other offenses.
About $8 billion in customer funds disappeared through opaque flows of money between FTX and its sister company, Alameda Research.
The whole crypto market crashed, with Bitcoin falling to around $16,000, and the "crypto winter" deepened.
FTX proved the point of "Not your keys, not your coins" all over again, and it pushed forward the debate about Proof of Reserves and custody rules.
Bankman-Fried was sentenced to 25 years in prison in 2024. On 12 June 2026 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit rejected his appeal outright, and the mandate issued on 4 August 2026. On 10 September 2026 he petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari, which is pending. He has also filed a pardon application, still pending as of August 2026, though the U.S. Senate adopted by unanimous consent a resolution opposing any pardon or commutation.
The bankruptcy estate, by contrast, has recovered far more than anyone expected at the outset. The reorganization plan was confirmed in October 2024, and through the fifth distribution on 31 July 2026 general unsecured claims (Classes 6A and 6B) reached a cumulative 103% and convenience claims (Class 7) a cumulative 120%. Those percentages, however, are measured against dollar valuations as of the November 2022 petition date. Because the BTC price rose sharply between then and 2026, creditors who had deposited crypto are substantially worse off than if their assets had been returned in kind. That is a persistent criticism, and the reason a nominal figure above 100% cannot be read as "the losses have been made whole."
7Mt.Gox — 10-year creditor repayment (2024–2026)
Nearly a decade after the 2014 collapse, the Japanese civil rehabilitation proceedings reached the point of paying creditors, starting in July 2024.
The total came to about 142,000 BTC and 143,000 BCH (Bitcoin Cash, which came out of the 2017 hard fork).
Creditors could choose between cash and repayment in kind, in actual BTC and BCH. Most chose in kind.
At the time of the collapse bitcoin traded around $450, a small fraction of its 2024 value, so many creditors became accidental long-term holders sitting on returns of more than 100x.
The market feared that returning so many coins at once would create selling pressure, but most of them were held and the impact was muted.
The process is still not finished as of October 20, 2026. The trustee announced on October 16, 2026 that, with court permission, the deadlines for base repayments, intermediate repayments, and early lump-sum repayments were moved to October 31, 2027; the trustee reported in March 2025 that more than 19,500 creditors had received repayments in BTC and BCH through designated cryptocurrency exchanges, while others remain unpaid, mainly because of incomplete paperwork and unresolved verification issues. On-chain data from the analytics firm Arkham Intelligence showed about 34,689 BTC still in Mt. Gox-linked wallets as of October 2025.
Trustee Nobuaki Kobayashi ran the decade of international legal and technical work, and the case became a landmark for crypto asset bankruptcy proceedings.
8Privacy tool prosecutions (2024)
On April 24, 2024 the U.S. DOJ arrested two operators of Samourai Wallet on charges of "unlicensed money transmission" and "money laundering conspiracy." Their CoinJoin service "Whirlpool" was at the center of the case.
The service never held user keys, and its operators argued that they never held customer funds, but prosecutors treated the overall flow of the service as money transmission.
Later that April, zkSNACKs, which runs Wasabi Wallet, blocked U.S. users and withdrew from the U.S. market. The following month it announced that its CoinJoin coordination service would shut down on June 1, 2024, and Trezor Suite, which relied on that coordinator, discontinued its CoinJoin feature for all users on the same date.
In August 2023 Roman Storm, a co-founder of the Ethereum privacy mixer Tornado Cash, was indicted and arrested. On August 6, 2025, a jury convicted him of conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money-transmitting business and deadlocked on the money-laundering and sanctions conspiracy counts. In an order dated August 25, 2026, the court postponed the retrial to April 26, 2027, in light of his pending motion for acquittal and the defense request for a continuance. On September 10, the court denied a motion to dismiss the remaining counts under the Speedy Trial Act; this was not a ruling on the Rule 29 motion for acquittal. Prosecutors submitted supplemental authority on venue on October 5, and in an October 9 letter, the defense argued that the cited decision did not support the prosecution's venue arguments. In a letter dated October 16, prosecutor Thane Rehn requested removal as counsel because he was leaving the U.S. Attorney's Office for other employment. Document 308 includes the court's endorsement dated the same day, granting the request and directing the clerk to remove him from the docket. This order concerns counsel's removal, not the Rule 29 motion for acquittal or sentencing.
This account uses copies of filings preserved by RECAP and the docket listing. The cited docket listing and archived copies correspond to archive identifier 604938. The ECF header on the August 25 order reads Document 300, but the September 10 order cites that adjournment order as Dkt. 299. The copy marked Document 299 is a separate order dated August 4. The citation-number discrepancy remains unresolved, and we do not treat it as a confirmed clerical error. These are not originals obtained directly from the court. The docket listing checked on October 21 dated Document 308 to October 19, while the ECF header and endorsement in the RECAP copy now obtained from Internet Archive are dated October 16. The reason for that date difference and the completeness of subsequent court records in the free archives remain unverified.
Inside the Bitcoin community, the clash between "privacy is not a crime" and the regulators' view of "privacy tools = money-laundering facilitation" has grown sharp. The two Samourai operators pleaded guilty in July 2025, with the money-laundering conspiracy charge dropped and the unlicensed money-transmitting charge left standing, and in November 2025 they were sentenced to five and four years in prison respectively. More cases of this kind are likely.
9Regulatory milestones
2013: FinCEN, part of the U.S. Treasury, issued guidance for Bitcoin businesses, one of the first major government moves to recognize Bitcoin inside a regulatory framework.
2017: Japan's amended Payment Services Act, passed the year before, took effect in April, defining crypto assets in law (then called "virtual currencies") and placing exchanges under a registration regime. It was the first national registration system among major economies, though not the world's first licensing scheme: New York State's BitLicense came earlier, in June 2015.
2021: El Salvador adopted Bitcoin as legal tender, the first country to do so. In January 2025, against the background of a financing agreement with the IMF, that legal-tender status was repealed and acceptance went back to being voluntary for businesses.
2023: The EU adopted MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets), a comprehensive regulatory framework for crypto assets.
2024: The U.S. SEC approved spot Bitcoin ETFs. BlackRock, Fidelity, and other large managers entered, bringing tens of billions of dollars in inflows.
2025: The United States established the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, and the GENIUS Act, covering stablecoin regulation, was signed into law, moving broader crypto regulation forward.
Around the world, Bitcoin regulation is shifting from "ban" to "coexistence through regulation."
Primary sources
- U.S. District Court - Endorsed letter granting counsel removal (dated October 16, 2026; Document 308; RECAP copy on Internet Archive)
- Internet Archive - RECAP file inventory for the Storm case (archive 604938)
- Bitcoin Core - Disclosure of CVE-2018-17144 (September 20, 2018; affected versions and mechanism)
- Bitcoin Forum: primary record of the 2010 overflow bug response
- Satoshi Nakamoto - Bitcoin 0.3.10 Release (August 15, 2010)
- Mt.Gox Rehabilitation Trustee — Notice Concerning Change of Repayments Deadline (October 27, 2025; English translation for reference)
- IRS — Samourai Wallet Founders Sentencing Announcement
- The White House — Establishment of the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve
- Japan FSA — Report from the Study Group on Virtual Currency Exchange Services (December 21, 2018; provisional translation)
- FTX Recovery Trust - press release on the fifth distribution (2026-07-17)
- Bybit — security incident timeline (official)
- Binance - Security Breach Update (7 May 2019; theft announcement and 30 October 2026 note)
- Changpeng Zhao - Decision not to pursue a reorg (8 May 2019; Internet Archive copy)
- mempool.space - The 7,000 BTC withdrawal from Binance (block 575,013)
- Binance - Security Incident Update (30 October 2026)
- Binance - Recovery Update #4: withdrawals resume in phases (1 November 2026)
- Japan FSA — Actions taken regarding virtual currency exchange service providers (Study Group on Virtual Currency Exchange Services, 5th meeting, Material 3, September 12, 2018; Japanese)
- Mt.Gox: civil rehabilitation commencement (2018-06-22)
- Mt.Gox: repayment deadline change (2026-10-16)
- U.S. District Court - RECAP copy of retrial adjournment order (August 25, 2026; ECF header: Document 300)
- U.S. Attorney - RECAP copy of supplemental authority on venue (October 5, 2026; ECF header: Document 305)
- US DOJ: Bankman-Fried arrest and charges (December 13, 2022)
- U.S. District Court - RECAP copy of Speedy Trial Act order (September 10, 2026; Document 303)
- RECAP docket - entries through October 19 (corresponding to archive 604938)
- U.S. District Court - RECAP copy of letter with August 4, 2026 order (Document 299)
- RECAP docket - August 25 order filing entry (entry 300; archive 604938)
- RECAP docket - October 5 prosecution letter filing entry (entry 305; archive 604938)
- Defense - RECAP copy of venue response (October 9, 2026; Document 306)
- U.S. Attorney - RECAP copy of counsel-removal request (October 16, 2026; Document 307)
Read next
Bitcoin ETFs & Institutional Adoption14 min readRelated topics
Advanced articles
Citation
- Title
- Incidents & Turning Points
- Source
- Bitcoin Library (bitcoin.ne.jp)
- Canonical URL
- https://bitcoin.ne.jp/en/learn/incidents
- Author
- KK siiiiiixth
- Topic
- incidents
- Published
- Updated
- Last verified
- Editorial policy
- https://bitcoin.ne.jp/en/editorial-policy
- License
- Content reuse terms
Operator-owned article text, original diagrams, and public data may be used for citation, summarization, indexing, search, RAG, machine analysis, and AI model training. When content is presented to readers, identify Bitcoin Library and the applicable canonical URL where technically practicable.
Note:This topic contains time-sensitive facts (regulation, tax, markets, ETFs, monetary policy). When citing via AI / LLM, please verify the Published / Updated date and Primary sources above, and prefer the most recent official primary sources (FSA / NTA / SEC / Congress.gov / White House / ESMA / FATF / BIS, etc.).
Revision history
- Distinguished protocol defects from exchange losses and corrected the Bybit account. Obtained Document 308 in the Storm case and recorded the order granting the prosecutor's removal as counsel. Corrected the 2019 Binance theft to match Binance's announcement (method, withdrawal path, and compensation as announced), and added the abandoned reorg proposal and the 30 October 2026 incident.
- Added the September 10 Storm order and the October 9 letter filing record, distinguishing them from a Rule 29 ruling or sentencing. Identified the unresolved case-ID and citation-number discrepancies between RECAP copies and the docket listing, distinguishing these from direct court originals. Verified the October 9 defense response and October 16 prosecution counsel-removal request from additional free copies. Corrected the docket-to-archive mapping and retained the limits on the October 19 filing text and citation discrepancy.
- Updated the Mt. Gox repayment deadlines and corrected the civil rehabilitation commencement date. Updated the Storm case from the court order and prosecution filing. Distinguished the FTX collapse from the date of its former CEO's arrest.
- Restated the Mt. Gox paid-creditor figure as the trustee reported it (more than 19,500 creditors repaid in BTC and BCH through designated exchanges, March 2025). Made the 2017 milestone precise: the amended Payment Services Act passed in 2016 and took effect in April 2017. Replaced the trustee-site and FSA homepage citations with the repayment-deadline notice (October 27, 2025) and the FSA study group report, and added the study group material on the business improvement orders.
- Attributed the remaining Mt. Gox BTC figure to Arkham rather than the trustee. Corrected the SBF entry (certiorari petition in September 2026; the Senate resolution was adopted by unanimous consent) and added the postponement of the Tornado Cash retrial to April 2027. Corrected the Wasabi/Trezor CoinJoin shutdown, the DMM Bitcoin attribution (NPA with the FBI and DC3), and the FBI naming and asset breakdown for Bybit.
- Outcomes brought up to date — Ulbricht pardon (both sides), FTX distributions at 103%/120% with the dollar-basis criticism, SBF appeal final, Storm retrial, Mt.Gox deadline, Coincheck compensation, Karpelès sentence; Bybit and DMM Bitcoin added to the exchange-hack section; Japan's "world-first licensing" claim corrected.